Five Questions Every B2B Founder Should Ask Their SEO Agency in 2026
Your rankings look fine. So why is the pipeline not growing?
You’re paying for SEO. Rankings are improving, and traffic might even be up. But the pipeline hasn’t moved, sales still lean on your personal network and the board wants to know what marketing is delivering. The problem might not be SEO itself. It might be that your agency is optimising for the wrong things.
SEO has changed more in the past three years than in the previous ten. Google now rewards proof of real-world experience over keyword volume, and tools like ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity answer questions before anyone clicks. These five questions will tell you whether your agency is keeping up or coasting.
Question One: What Is Your E-E-A-T Strategy for Our Site?
E-E-A-T stands for Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness and Trustworthiness, and it’s now central to how Google decides whether your content deserves to rank. The extra E, added in 2022, rewards proof that the writer has done the work rather than summarised someone else’s article. Named authors, case studies and documented client results all help. Generic, unsigned blog posts no longer cut it.
- Good answer: A specific plan covering author bios, case studies and trust signals, and how these connect to your target keywords.
- Bad answer: Silence, jargon or a vague mention of building more backlinks.
Question Two: How Are AI Overviews Affecting Our Traffic?
AI Overviews are the AI-generated answer boxes at the top of many Google results. They often answer the question outright, so fewer people click through, even if you rank first.
That isn’t your agency’s fault, but it is their job to adjust. If they haven’t raised it, either they don’t understand the shift or they’re hoping you won’t notice the dip.
- Good answer: They can show which keywords are affected, how click-through has shifted and what they’re doing about it, from targeting different queries to structuring content to appear in the Overview itself.
- Bad answer: “Our rankings are still strong.” Rankings without clicks are a vanity metric.
Question Three: Are We Optimising for AI Answer Engines as Well as Google?
This is where AEO (answer engine optimisation) comes in: structuring your content so AI tools cite it when they answer questions. It sits alongside SEO, not instead of it.
More of your potential clients ask ChatGPT or Perplexity for recommendations instead of Google. Without direct answers, clear definitions and named expertise, your content won’t get cited, and you’ll be invisible to them. Try it now: ask an AI tool who the leading firms are in your space. If your name doesn’t come up, that’s a gap.
For B2B businesses, a content strategy built for both SEO and AEO is no longer optional.
- Good answer: They know the difference between SEO and AEO, can explain how they’re structuring your content for AI citation and have tested how your brand shows up in AI tools.
- Bad answer: “We do not really do that” or “AI is just a trend.”
Question Four: What Are Our Top Five Keywords and Are They Driving Leads?
This is the commercial reality check. You can rank first for a term nobody with buying intent searches for, and it will look great in a monthly report while doing nothing for your business.
A good partner can name your top five keywords and show how each leads to enquiries, demo requests or whatever your main conversion point is.
- Good answer: Five specific keywords, tied to landing pages, with conversion data showing whether they bring in leads or just traffic.
- Bad answer: A list of 50 keywords ranked by search volume, with no mention of what happened after someone clicked.
Question Five: What Is the Monthly Action Plan and How Does It Tie to Commercial Outcomes?
Your agency should be able to tell you what they’re doing each month, why and what it should achieve in business terms. A report full of graphs and jargon with no line to results means you’re paying for motion, not progress.
And if your sales and marketing are not yet working from a shared definition of what good looks like, your SEO reports will always feel disconnected from the outcomes that matter.
- Good answer: A short, specific plan with clear priorities, timelines and expected outcomes tied to leads or revenue.
- Bad answer: “We published four blog posts and built twelve backlinks.”
What to Do With the Answers
Five strong answers? You’re in good hands. Two or three vague ones mean it’s time for a direct conversation about expectations. If none land, you’re paying for an outdated service.
Run This Test Before Your Next Agency Catch-Up
- Search your top five keywords on Google and note how many results are now dominated by AI Overviews.
- Ask ChatGPT or Perplexity a question your ideal client would ask, and check whether your business is cited.
- Pull last month’s SEO report and count how many metrics connect directly to leads or pipeline. Fewer than three, and you have the evidence you need for a better conversation.
Rankings are a means to an end. These five questions are a good place to start. Use them.
Not Sure Where Your SEO and AEO Stand?
If you’d like a second pair of eyes, book a free 20-minute Connect Call. No jargon, no upsell, just an honest look at what’s working and what isn’t.
About the Author
Aoife Ross is the founder of Connected Content, an Irish content agency working with ambitious businesses across the UK and Ireland. With over 20 years in marketing, sales and content strategy, Aoife helps B2B founders plan, produce and distribute content that drives commercial results. Connect with Aoife on LinkedIn