Getting the Best from Your Agency: A Guide to Better Partnerships
You don’t hire an agency to follow instructions. You hire one to get results. That only happens when the relationship is structured, respectful and built on shared accountability.
Having worked both agency-side and client-side, I’ve seen what makes projects fly and what makes them crash. Here’s what I’ve learned.
This post is part of a series on working with a marketing agency:
- How to Brief a Marketing Agency
- What to Expect from a Marketing Agency Proposal
- How to Evaluate an Agency Pitch
- Getting the Best from Your Marketing Agency
Why agency partnerships fail before they begin
Plenty of projects go sideways before they start. Usually the agency wasn’t wrong for the job. Not enough thought went into choosing them.
Agencies put hours, sometimes days, into proposals nobody reads properly. They’re shortlisted, then rushed through a 30-minute pitch for a six-month project. The brief is vague and the goals are undefined, so everyone wonders why the first month feels like groundwork.
If you want great work from your agency, start before the pitch:
- Shortlist carefully: Choose agencies whose experience matches what you need, not the ones with the best-looking website.
- Brief clearly: A vague brief gets vague work. Say what you need, why you need it and what success looks like.
- Set realistic goals: Agree what’s achievable within the timeline and budget before work begins.
- Stay engaged: An agency can’t read minds. If you disappear after the kick-off, don’t be surprised when the work misses the mark.
Stop treating your agency like a supplier
You’ve trusted an agency with your brand, your campaigns or your content. Give them the space and support to do their best work.
A good agency won’t say yes to everything. They’ll challenge assumptions, ask awkward questions and bring experience you don’t have in-house. That’s what you’re paying for. When they push back, don’t take it personally. You’re on the same side.
An agency that agrees with everything you say isn’t an agency. It’s an expensive pair of hands.
How a good agency partnership works
It comes down to clear expectations, consistent communication and shared ownership of the outcome.
- Agree how you’ll communicate: Daily updates? A weekly report? A standing call? Say so at the outset, and if you’re unsure what’s being delivered or why something is taking longer, ask. Unspoken expectations are where most agency relationships quietly fall apart.
- Define what success looks like: “A better website” means different things to different people. Agree success criteria early and get every stakeholder on board before work begins. A finished project picked apart at the last minute because someone senior wasn’t consulted is one of the most avoidable, and expensive, problems in agency work.
- Revisit expectations as things change: Priorities shift. That’s fine, as long as both sides acknowledge it and agree what changes as a result.
Let your agency make a profit
This one is rarely said out loud. It should be.
Good agencies don’t overcharge, but they shouldn’t be asked to run on goodwill either. If a project isn’t commercially viable for them, you won’t get their best people. Over time you’ll slip down the priority list and the quality will drop.
Negotiate on price if you need to, but be fair. You’re not buying hours, you’re paying for outcomes.
Control scope creep before it controls you
Scope creep is one of the most common reasons agency projects run over budget and over time.
Look at the National Children’s Hospital in Ireland, which is expected to cost several times its original estimate. The reasons will be familiar to anyone who has worked on a complex project:
- Clarity: The scope wasn’t defined well enough at the outset.
- Alignment: Stakeholders didn’t agree on priorities.
- Pricing: There was no fixed framework for managing additions and changes.
- Decisions: Choices were made under pressure rather than through a structured process.
That’s a communication problem as much as a construction one, and agency projects can follow exactly the same pattern if nobody defines the edges of the work. Agree what’s in scope, write it down and hold both sides to it. Additions are fine once they’ve been discussed, prioritised and costed.
And if your sales and marketing are already pulling in different directions, bringing an agency in on an undefined brief will only speed up the chaos.
Six habits of clients who get great work
- Briefing: They put time into a clear, specific brief before work begins.
- Communication: They set a working rhythm and stick to it.
- Engagement: They stay involved without micromanaging.
- Presence: They don’t vanish halfway through and expect a polished result.
- Fairness: They don’t expect exceptional work for a price that can’t support it.
- Openness: When the agency asks hard questions, they listen.
Get the basics right and great work becomes possible. Get them wrong and even the best agency in the world will struggle.
Working with an agency, or thinking about it?
If you’re about to bring an agency on board, or wondering why the current arrangement isn’t working, I’m happy to talk it through. Book a free 20-minute Connect Call and we’ll have an honest chat about where things stand.