What to Expect From an Agency Proposal
You sent out a strong brief. The proposals have landed. Now comes the part that catches a lot of business owners out: working out which one is worth the investment and which one is just well designed.
A polished document isn’t the same as a well-considered one, and a long proposal isn’t the same as a thorough one.
This post is part of a series covering briefing agencies, assessing proposals, scoring a pitch and building a relationship with your marketing agency.
- How to Brief a Marketing Agency
- What to Expect From a Marketing Agency Proposal
- How to Evaluate an Agency Pitch
- Getting the Best From Your Marketing Agency
What a good agency proposal includes
A clear understanding of your brief
First, check whether they’ve read what you sent. A strong proposal opens by restating your challenge in your terms, not theirs. If the opening pages could apply to any client in any sector, the agency is probably recycling a template.
A practical, outcome-focused approach
Look for a plan, not a menu. What will they do, in what order and why? Agencies that lead with a list of services rather than outcomes tend to be more focused on what they like to sell than what you need to buy.
Named people, not just a logo
Good proposals explain who will work on your account day to day and what they bring, not just a page of headshots. If the humans are hidden behind the brand, ask who you’ll be dealing with once the contract is signed.
Transparent pricing
Full breakdown or summary figure, you should be able to see what you’re paying for and why. Watch out for vague line items, lots of “from” pricing and costs that only appear once you’re committed.
A realistic timeline
Broad phases, such as discovery, build and review, are practical and honest. A detailed week-by-week schedule before work has started is often telling you what you want to hear. Flexibility at this stage is a sign of experience, not vagueness.
Defined success metrics
A strong proposal ties success back to the goals in your brief. If your goal was lead generation, it should say how leads will be tracked, what counts as qualified and how that will be reported. Vague talk of “improving visibility” or “increasing engagement” with no commercial anchor suggests accountability isn’t built into how this agency works.
Red flags in an agency proposal
- All style: It looks impressive but says very little. Design isn’t strategy.
- Nothing about you: No reference to your brief, goals or audience. Generic content signals a generic approach.
- Murky pricing: Unclear, heavily caveated or only available on request.
- Too much about them: Their history, awards and clients take centre stage. You’re not paying for their trophy cabinet.
- A different team: The people in the proposal aren’t the people you’ll work with.
- No measure of success: Without it, accountability is optional.
How to compare proposals side by side
The temptation is to compare on price, which is rarely the best place to start. Instead, score each proposal against these questions:
- Does it reflect our brief accurately?
- Does it address our specific goals?
- Is the approach practical and commercially grounded?
- Are the team and their experience clearly presented?
- Is pricing transparent and easy to understand?
- Is there a clear plan for measuring success?
A proposal that scores well on all six at a higher price is almost always better value than a cheaper one that glosses over three of them. Scope creep, miscommunication and mismatched expectations cost more in the long run than the difference in the initial fee.
What happens after the proposal
A strong agency won’t send a document and wait. It will follow up, invite questions and walk you through its thinking, which tells you a lot about how it will communicate once the work starts. Ask to meet the team. Ask how they handle scope changes and what happens when a project runs into problems.
If you’d like to see how we approach client relationships before a single brief is written, take a look at our process.
Want a second opinion before you choose?
We don’t send proposals to tick a box. If you’re weighing up agency proposals and want an honest outside view, book a free 20-minute Connect Call. I’ll tell you what I’d look for in your shoes.